How we check tools
Transparency first
Checked before it's listed, and every day it's live
Every tool on FolioNames goes through the same checks, whoever made it. Here is each one: what it looks at, when it runs, and what happens if a tool fails it.
Once a day
Uptime check on every live tool
Every 6 hours
Watch for new scripts, frames and forms
Every night
Security scan, safety checks and speed test
Before listing
Review, risk level and Google Safe Browsing
The checks, in order
From the moment a tool is submitted to every day it stays on the site.
Stage 1
Before it's listed
Automated reviewMakers' tools
A Claude-powered review checks the tool is legitimate and that what it asks for matches what it claims, and looks for phishing or misleading claims. A person looks at anything it flags.
Editor checkTools we add
An editor checks the tools our team adds from their public websites, and confirms the key facts against the tool's own pages.
Risk levelEvery tool
Each tool is graded Minimal, Limited, Elevated, High or Unacceptable. Sensitive permissions such as camera, microphone, location and payment raise the level.
Google Safe Browsing and HTTPSEvery tool
The site must use HTTPS and must not be on Google's list of unsafe sites.
Stage 2
Every day it's live
UptimeOnce a day
We check the site answers. Each night the last 30 days of checks become its Reliability score.
Page changesEvery 6 hours
We watch for scripts, frames or form destinations from websites no review has seen.
Security scanNightly
HTTPS, key security headers, and any exposed .git or .env file.
Safety checksNightly
Privacy policy, terms, contact details, trackers, forms, security headers and domain age (see below).
Speed and accessibilityNightly
Google PageSpeed measures how fast the site loads and how usable it is for everyone.
Google Safe BrowsingNightly
Every live site is checked against Google's list of unsafe sites again.
Stage 3
When something fails
Down for too long6 checks in a row
A tool that fails 6 uptime checks in a row is suspended (new listings get a 24-hour grace period). It comes back on its own after 3 healthy checks.
Serious security finding2 scans in a row
A high-severity finding on two nightly scans in a row suspends the tool until it's fixed. Missing headers alone never do.
Code from a new websiteSeen twice
A new script, frame or form destination seen on two checks in a row takes the tool off the site until it's reviewed again.
Flagged as unsafeNext check
A Google Safe Browsing flag fails the safety checks and sets the tool's Safety score to 0.
A fault on our sideOver a fifth down
If more than a fifth of tools look down at the same time, we assume the problem is ours and suspend nothing.
How we score apps: the FolioScore
Every listing gets one score out of 100, shown in a circle on its card and page. It's the average of five parts:
Speed
Google PageSpeed
How fast the site loads on a phone.
Accessibility
Google PageSpeed
How usable it is for everyone, including people using screen readers or keyboards.
Reliability
Our uptime checks
The share of our 15-minute checks it answered over the last 30 days, shown once it has a day of checks.
Ratings
Reviews
What signed-in reviewers say, weighted so one review can't swing it.
Safety
Our safety checks
The safety checks below, averaged with the AI risk review where there is one. A Google Safe Browsing flag makes it 0.
- How many people use a tool isn't part of the score, so new tools aren't marked down.
- A score needs at least three parts measured. Until then the circle shows a dash, and hovering over it says why.
- For a tool's first week the circle has a dashed ring: the score is provisional.
- Hover over any circle to see each part.
Safety checks: the same for every app
Every live listing is checked each night, and as soon as it's published, using only evidence anyone could repeat. No AI and no paid service is involved, so every tool is treated the same, whoever made it.
Points for each check
- Security headers18 points
A Content Security Policy (8), HSTS (6) and nosniff (4).
- Privacy policy16 points
Found from the page's links or its usual address.
- Domain age12 points
From the public registration record: full marks at two years or more.
- No advertising trackers10 points
2.5 points off for each tracker the page loads.
- Forms10 points
Sending data anywhere other than the site or a known payment, sign-in or form service costs points; a password sent elsewhere costs them all.
- Terms of use8 points
Found from the page's links or their usual address.
- Contact details8 points
An email address, phone number, or contact or about page.
- No insecure content6 points
Nothing loaded over plain http on a secure page.
- Domain ownership6 points
The maker has proved they own the domain. It doesn't apply to a listing no maker has claimed yet, so it neither helps nor hurts that listing's score.
The score is the share of the points that could be measured, so a check that couldn't run neither helps nor hurts. At least 40 points' worth must be measurable for a score.
Fails outright
- A Google Safe Browsing flag
- No HTTPS
- An exposed .env or .git file
A higher bar for sensitive tools
For health, legal, finance, education, government and politics tools, the privacy policy, terms and contact details count half again, because mistakes there cost people most.
What our checks can't tell you
- They don't test every feature inside a tool, or judge how good its answers are.
- They can't see behind a sign-in, so paid areas aren't checked.
- A good score isn't a guarantee: read a tool's own terms before sharing personal or sensitive information.
- How popular a tool is never changes its score.
Seen a problem?
Use Report on any listing to tell us about a broken, misleading or unsafe tool, and we'll look at it. For a security issue in FolioNames itself, see Reporting a vulnerability below.
